Journal article · 2021

Brothers in Arms: Spillovers from a Draft Lottery

Journal of Human Resources, 56(1), 225–268, 2021 (with Petter Lundborg and Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen)

Abstract

Family members tend to have similar labor market outcomes, but measuring the contribution of behavioral spillovers is difficult. To identify spillovers between brothers, we exploit Denmark's largest random assignment of young men to 8 months of military service where service status of brothers is correlated but draft lottery numbers are not. We find average spillovers of elder brother service on younger brother service of 7 percent, and as high as 55 percent for closely spaced brothers without sisters. Elder brother military service affects his own occupational choice and his younger brother's service through private information, thereby encouraging volunteering.

Finding

Effect of an elder brother's military service on a younger brother's service A younger brother's service has no effect on his elder brother. An elder brother's service raises a younger brother's chance of serving by about 3 percentage points on average, rising to 26 points for three closely spaced brothers with no sisters, with a wide interval. Placebo: younger brother → elder 0 Elder → younger, all pairs +3 pts …born within 3 years +5 pts …with a third brother +8 pts …three close brothers, no sisters +26 pts 0 10 20 30 40 50 Change in chance of serving (percentage points)

An elder brother sent to serve makes his younger brother more likely to serve.

Brothers often make similar choices, but it is hard to tell whether they influence each other or just share a background. Denmark draws lottery numbers for each brother separately, so an elder brother sent to serve by chance lets us measure his pull on the younger one. It raises the younger brother's chance of serving by 7 percent on average, and by 55 percent among three closely spaced brothers with no sisters. A younger brother's service does nothing to his elder brother, so the influence runs one way.

Dots are IV estimates with 95% intervals. The top row is a placebo test of the reverse direction. Each lower row narrows the sample to closer brothers.

Cite

@article{bingley2021brothers,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Petter Lundborg and Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen},
  title   = {Brothers in Arms: Spillovers from a Draft Lottery},
  journal = {Journal of Human Resources},
  volume  = {56},
  number  = {1},
  pages   = {225-268},
  year    = {2021},
  doi     = {10.3368/jhr.56.1.0317-8646r3}
}

All publications