Journal article · 2019

Correlation of Brothers' Earnings and Intergenerational Transmission

The Review of Economics and Statistics, 101(2), 370–383, 2019 (with Lorenzo Cappellari)

Abstract

We model the correlations of brothers' earnings isolating the effect of fathers' earnings from additional residual influences shared between brothers. We separate the two effects by analysing sibling correlations and intergenerational correlations jointly within a unified framework. Our multi-person model of earnings dynamics distinguishes permanent from transitory shocks, allows for heterogeneous life cycle effects and nests previous models. Using data on the Danish population of father/first-son/second-son triplets, we corroborate the findings of studies that do not account for life cycle effects for those aged in their 30's, but find correlations twice as large at 25. The impact of intergenerational effects also varies over age, but is everywhere higher than found in previous studies ?by on average a factor of thirteen? and accounts for most of the sibling correlation. We provide evidence that lack of both life cycle effects and heterogeneous intergenerational transmission across families in previous studies explain the difference. When allowing for differential intergenerational transmission within families, we find mild evidence of stronger transmission to second sons.

Finding

Share of the correlation between brothers' earnings that comes from transmission from the father Earlier studies, which assume transmission works the same way in every family, put the share of the sibling earnings correlation due to intergenerational transmission at 6 percent. Allowing transmission to differ between families raises it to 72 percent. Earlier studies 6% Allowing families to differ 72% 0 20 40 60 80 Share of the sibling correlation (%) The brothers' earnings correlate 0.22 over the life cycle.

Transmission from the father accounts for 72 percent of how alike brothers earn.

Brothers' earnings resemble each other, and the standard reading is that parents account for little of it, with shared schools, neighbourhoods and friends doing the work. Those shares came from calibrations that assume transmission works the same way in every family. Using Danish father and two-son triads we measure it directly and let families differ. The sibling correlation averages 0.22 over the life cycle, and 72 percent of it is intergenerational.

Bars are the share of the brothers' earnings correlation that comes from transmission from the father. The correlation itself is U-shaped over the life cycle, which no earlier study could see.

Cite

@article{bingley2019correlation,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Lorenzo Cappellari},
  title   = {Correlation of Brothers' Earnings and Intergenerational Transmission},
  journal = {The Review of Economics and Statistics},
  volume  = {101},
  number  = {2},
  pages   = {370-383},
  year    = {2019},
  doi     = {10.1162/rest\_a\_00753}
}

All publications