Journal article · 2026

Earnings Dynamics, Inequality, and Firm Heterogeneity

Journal of Applied Econometrics, 41(2), 169–194, 2026 (with Lorenzo Cappellari)

Abstract

Studies of individual earnings dynamics typically overlook firm heterogeneity, while worker and firm decompositions of earnings inequality often neglect the life cycle. We study firm effects in individual earnings dynamics for the Italian private sector population, using the covariance structure of co‐worker earnings for identification. We allow for dynamics of both worker and firm effects, as well as worker‐firm sorting and worker segregation. When workers are young, firm and worker heterogeneity explain similar shares of earnings inequality; however, over the life cycle, workers account for most of the inequality. Sorting is substantial, especially among younger workers. Segregation accounts for most of the earnings inequality between firms.

Finding

Share of earnings inequality explained by firms and by workers, early and late in a career Firm heterogeneity explains about a quarter of earnings dispersion at age 30 and 8 percent by the mid-fifties, by which point permanent differences between workers explain about 70 percent. Firms, at age 30 25% Firms, mid-fifties 8% Workers, mid-fifties 70% 0 20 40 60 80 Share of earnings inequality (%)

The firm explains a quarter of the earnings gap at 30, and 8 percent by the mid-fifties.

Work on earnings dynamics usually leaves firms out, and work on firm pay premiums usually leaves the life cycle out. We identify both together from the covariance of co-workers' earnings in the Italian private sector. At 30, firms account for about a quarter of earnings dispersion and worker-firm sorting for a fifth. By the mid-fifties firms account for 8 percent and permanent differences between workers for about 70 percent.

Each bar is a share of the total variance of earnings at the age shown. Ignoring the tendency of similar workers to end up together overstates sorting by a factor of two.

Cite

@article{bingley2026earnings,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Lorenzo Cappellari},
  title   = {Earnings Dynamics, Inequality, and Firm Heterogeneity},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Econometrics},
  volume  = {41},
  number  = {2},
  pages   = {169-194},
  year    = {2026},
  doi     = {10.1002/jae.70024}
}

All publications