Working paper · 2026

Helping the Many by Tutoring the Few: The Social Multiplier of Early Literacy Instruction

EdWorkingPaper 26-1562, Annenberg Institute at Brown University, 2026 (with Jens Dietrichson, Mette Friis-Hansen and Vibeke Myrup Jensen)

Abstract

Tutoring is almost always evaluated by randomizing students within schools, a design that differences out any spillover onto classmates. We instead randomize 81 Danish schools and 2,583 kindergartners, tutoring a few children in each and testing all. Decoding improved 0.38 standard deviations among the pre-registered target group and 0.27 SD school-wide. Bounds requiring only the test’s range and random assignment show that never-tutored peers gained at least 0.19 SD, implying a social multiplier of at least three. Tutors were the schools’ own staff, so costs were low. Evaluations of targeted tutoring understate its value two- to threefold.

Finding

Standard trials understate the gains from tutoring The lower bound on the social multiplier is 3.2 at the observed tutoring share of 0.171, 2.0 to 3.7 across shares 0.15 to 0.25, and falls to 1 at a share of 0.40. Plausible range No gain to classmates At least 3× at the share schools tutored 1× 2× 3× 4× 5× 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% Share of pupils a school would tutor True gain vs. what a standard trial sees

Tutoring a few kindergartners raised reading for the whole school.

Tutoring trials usually randomise pupils within schools, which nets out any benefit to classmates. We randomised 81 Danish schools and 2,583 kindergartners, tutored a few in each and tested all of them. Decoding rose 0.38 standard deviations in the pre-registered target group and 0.27 school-wide. Bounds needing only random assignment and the test's range put the gain to never-tutored peers at 0.19 SD or more, so evaluating tutoring within schools understates its value two- to threefold.

The line is a lower bound, built only from random assignment and the test's score range.

Cite

No DOI record was found for this entry, so the citation below carries only what the list itself states.

@misc{bingley2026helping,
  author       = {Paul Bingley and Jens Dietrichson and Mette Friis-Hansen and Vibeke Myrup Jensen},
  title        = {Helping the Many by Tutoring the Few: The Social Multiplier of Early Literacy Instruction},
  howpublished = {EdWorkingPaper 26-1562, Annenberg Institute at Brown University, 2026},
  year         = {2026},
  url          = {https://doi.org/10.26300/xnz7-3z53}
}

All publications