Journal article · 2022

Military Service and Skill Acquisition: Evidence from a Draft Lottery

Journal of Human Capital, 16(3), 403–429, 2022 (with Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen and Anders Rosdahl)

Abstract

Millions of young people worldwide are subject to military conscription. While the effects of conscription on educational attainment have been widely studied, little is known about effects on skills. To estimate military service effects on skills, we use the Danish draft lottery and skills measures from the Program for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies. While service is associated with relatively poor skills, we find positive causal effects on numeracy and literacy measured 10 years after service. Service effects are largest for men with low scores in Armed Forces Qualification Tests, who are more likely to complete vocational training after service.

Finding

Effect of military service on adult numeracy and literacy by position in the forces' qualification test Among men in the lowest third of the Armed Forces Qualification Test, service raises numeracy by 22 percent of a standard deviation and literacy by 16 percent. In the middle third numeracy rises 24 percent. In the highest third neither effect is statistically significant. 0 10 20 22 16 Lowest third 24 n.s. Middle third n.s. n.s. Highest third Armed Forces Qualification Test at 18 Numeracy Literacy Effect, % of a standard deviation

Conscription raised the literacy only of the men who tested worst.

Conscription is usually judged by what it costs in earnings and schooling, seldom by what it teaches. We match the Danish draft lottery to adult skills measured about ten years after service. Service raises numeracy and literacy by 7 to 10 percent of a standard deviation. The literacy gain belongs entirely to men who scored in the lowest third of the forces' own test at 18, and the numeracy gain to the lowest and middle thirds. For the lowest third it offsets 45 percent of their literacy shortfall.

Bars are instrumental variable estimates of the effect of serving, by third of the Armed Forces Qualification Test. Men in the lowest and middle thirds are also more likely to complete vocational training after service.

Cite

@article{bingley2022military,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen and Anders Rosdahl},
  title   = {Military Service and Skill Acquisition: Evidence from a Draft Lottery},
  journal = {Journal of Human Capital},
  volume  = {16},
  number  = {3},
  pages   = {404-436},
  year    = {2022},
  doi     = {10.1086/719950}
}

All publications