Working paper · 2024

On the Origins of Socioeconomic Inequalities: Evidence from Twin Families

LISER Working Paper 2024-03, 2024 (with Lorenzo Cappellari and Konstantinos Tatsiramos)

Abstract

Using Danish Twins Registry and population data, we link twins with their relatives to evaluate the controversial assumptions of the classic twin model and decompose socioeconomic inequality into genetic (heritability) and environmental factors. We reject the equal environments assumption, finding that the classic model overestimates heritability. Heritability explains 9% of variation in education and 14-16% in earnings, income, and wealth, helping to fill the ‘missing heritability’ gap between the classic twin model and Genome-Wide Association Studies. Shared environments account for 26-42% of these variances and 45-81% of intergenerational persistence. These findings reconcile estimates from twin and adoptee studies.

Finding

Share of the variance explained by heritability, under the classic twin design and after relaxing its equal-environments assumption Heritability falls from 34 to 9 percent for schooling, 60 to 16 for earnings, 56 to 14 for disposable income and 42 to 14 for wealth, once the degree of environmental sharing is allowed to differ between identical and fraternal twin pairs. 0 20 40 60 Schooling 9 34 Earnings 16 60 Disposable income 14 56 Wealth 14 42 Heritability, % of the variance Twin-family model Classic twin design

Testing the twin model's equal-environments assumption cuts the heritability of schooling from 34 to 9 percent.

The classic twin design reads any excess similarity between identical pairs as genetic, which holds only if identical and fraternal pairs share their environments to the same degree. Linking the Danish Twin Registry to the twins' spouses and children identifies the model without assuming it, and the assumption is rejected. Heritability falls from 34 to 9 percent of the variance in schooling and from 60 to 16 percent in earnings. Shared family environment accounts for 42 and 26 percent.

Not every relaxation of the model lowers heritability: allowing assortative mating on genes raises the schooling estimate to 45 percent, and the data show no genetic dominance. At 9 percent, schooling sits nearer the 4 to 5 percent that direct genetic effects in genome-wide studies imply than the 40 percent twin designs usually return. Danish twin families, twins born around 1950.

Cite

No DOI record was found for this entry, so the citation below carries only what the list itself states.

@misc{bingley2024origins,
  author       = {Paul Bingley and Lorenzo Cappellari and Konstantinos Tatsiramos},
  title        = {On the Origins of Socioeconomic Inequalities: Evidence from Twin Families},
  howpublished = {LISER Working Paper 2024-03, 2024},
  year         = {2024},
  url          = {https://liser.elsevierpure.com/en/publications/on-the-origins-of-socioeconomic-inequalities-evidence-from-twin-f/}
}

All publications