Journal article · 2024

Recruiting Effective Soldiers: Comparing Danish Conscripts and Volunteers Deployed to Peace-Keeping and Peace-Enforcing Missions

Labour Economics, 89, 102587, 2024 (with Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen)

Abstract

Several countries have changed between conscription and volunteer militaries, yet very little is known about the outcomes of conscripts compared with volunteers. Denmark is one of the few countries that recruits conscripts and volunteers for military service and assigns conscripts through a draft lottery—a uniquely informative combination. While deployment to the missions we study was voluntary, we use the initial assignment mechanism to estimate the relationships between recruitment methods and a variety of military and post-military deployment outcomes. We find that conscription improves the deployed intelligence pool compared to a volunteer force. However, the intelligence of deployed conscripts varies more over the business cycle than that of volunteers. Denmark’s mixed recruitment method is able to recruit effective soldiers as we find no other significant associations between recruitment method and outcomes while deployed.

Finding

Qualification test scores of deployed Danish soldiers by local unemployment and route into service Deployed soldiers who volunteered score 18 percent of a standard deviation below deployed conscripts. Conscripts' scores fall by 13 percent of a standard deviation for each point of local unemployment, volunteers' by 8 percent, so the two converge when unemployment is high. -0.6 -0.4 -0.2 0 +0.2 Conscripts Volunteers 2% 4% 6% 8% Local unemployment at deployment Test score, SD from a conscript at 4% The gap closes as unemployment rises.

A draft lottery brought in sharper soldiers than volunteering did.

Denmark recruits conscripts and volunteers at the same time and assigns the conscripts by lottery, which makes the two routes comparable. Among soldiers deployed to peacekeeping and peace-enforcing missions, those who had volunteered score 18 percent of a standard deviation below those who were drafted. Conscripts' scores also track the economy more closely, falling 13 percent of a standard deviation per point of local unemployment against 8 percent for volunteers.

Lines are fitted from the estimated coefficients, measured against a conscript deployed when local unemployment is 4 percent. On every other deployment outcome measured, the two routes are alike.

Cite

@article{bingley2024recruiting,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen},
  title   = {Recruiting Effective Soldiers: Comparing Danish Conscripts and Volunteers Deployed to Peace-Keeping and Peace-Enforcing Missions},
  journal = {Labour Economics},
  volume  = {89},
  pages   = {102587},
  year    = {2024},
  doi     = {10.1016/j.labeco.2024.102587}
}

All publications