Journal article · 2002

The Incidence of Income Tax on Wages and Labour Supply

Journal of Public Economics, 83(2), 173–194, 2002 (with Gauthier Lanot)

Abstract

In the simple framework of a static model for equilibrium wages and labour supplies, we show that the incidence of income tax on equilibrium wages can be measured independently from the individual labour supply elasticity. This extends recent work by [Journal of Labour Economics, 15(3) (1997) S72–S101] and [Journal of Public Economics, 65 (1997) 119–145], who estimate tax incidence on earnings, and [Econometrica, 66(4) (1998) 827–861] and [NBER Working Paper 5023 (1995)], who estimate labour supply elasticities. Our measurements are based on a large multi-level longitudinal data set of Danish private sector establishments and workers. We show that, allowing for labour supply response, there is strong evidence for partial shifting of the burden of income tax from worker to employer. Higher marginal tax rates are associated with increases in gross wages and earnings.

Finding

Elasticities of gross wages, gross earnings and labour supply with respect to the marginal income tax rate A higher marginal tax rate raises gross wages with an elasticity of 0.44 and gross earnings with an elasticity of 0.36, so part of the burden shifts to the employer. The labour supply elasticity with respect to the wage is 0.14. Gross wage, to the marginal tax rate 0.44 Gross earnings, to the marginal tax rate 0.36 Labour supply, to the wage 0.14 0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 Elasticity

Part of a rise in income tax lands on the employer.

Studies of how income tax changes work usually hold the gross wage fixed, so the whole of a tax change reaches the worker by construction. Using matched Danish establishment and worker records we let the wage adjust instead. A higher marginal rate raises gross wages with an elasticity of 0.44 and gross earnings with an elasticity of 0.36, so employers carry part of the burden though not all of it. Assuming no shifting overstates the incentive effect by about a factor of two.

All three elasticities come from one model estimated on establishment and worker panel data, and all are precisely measured.

Cite

@article{bingley2002incidence,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Gauthier Lanot},
  title   = {The Incidence of Income Tax on Wages and Labour Supply},
  journal = {Journal of Public Economics},
  volume  = {83},
  number  = {2},
  pages   = {173-194},
  year    = {2002},
  doi     = {10.1016/S0047-2727(01)00080-9}
}

All publications