Journal article · 2020

The Opportunity Costs of Mandatory Military Service: Evidence from a Draft Lottery

Journal of Labor Economics, 38(1), 39–66, 2020 (with Petter Lundborg and Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen)

Abstract

Conscription forces young men to serve in the military, irrespective of their opportunity costs. Using random assignment in the Danish draft lottery, we find a negative average effect of peacetime military service on earnings, an effect varying by ability, with high-ability men facing a $23,000 lifetime earnings penalty but with low-ability men facing none. This gradient is robust to different measures of labor market prospects. Educational disruption is an important mechanism, while service has little effect on health or criminal activity. The opportunity costs of conscription are borne by men with the best labor market prospects.

Finding

Effect of military service on earnings at ages 25 to 35, by quartile of the forces' qualification test Serving changes earnings by +1.3 percent in the lowest quartile and -1.4 in the second, neither significantly different from zero, by -2.9 in the third and by -7.1 percent in the highest. -10% -5% 0 +5% Lowest 2nd 3rd Highest −7% Cognitive ability at the draft board (quartile) Not significant Significant Effect of serving on earnings (%)

Among the men Denmark drafted, the ones with the best prospects paid the highest price.

Economists have long argued that conscription is a hidden tax, but not who pays it. Between 1994 and 2007, Denmark assigned military service by lottery after testing every recruit, so we can estimate the cost of serving separately by ability. Among men in the lowest quarter of the forces' test, serving leaves earnings at 25 to 35 unchanged. Among the highest quarter it lowers them 7 percent, a lifetime penalty of about $23,000, and part of it runs through schooling the service delayed.

Instrumental variable estimates of the effect of serving on log earnings at ages 25 to 35, by quartile of the Armed Forces Qualification Test, with 95% intervals. The two lower quartiles are not significantly different from zero.

Cite

@article{bingley2020opportunity,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Petter Lundborg and Stéphanie Vincent Lyk-Jensen},
  title   = {The Opportunity Costs of Mandatory Military Service: Evidence from a Draft Lottery},
  journal = {Journal of Labor Economics},
  volume  = {38},
  number  = {1},
  pages   = {39-66},
  year    = {2020},
  doi     = {10.1086/704495}
}

All publications