Journal article · 2026

When It Hurts the Most: Timing of Parental Job Loss and a Child's Education

Journal of the European Economic Association, advance article, 2026 (with Lorenzo Cappellari and Marco Ovidi)

Abstract

We estimate how the timing of parental job loss shapes children’s human capital by exploiting plant closures in Danish administrative data. We match treated children to observably similar untreated peers and difference out age-invariant selection using children whose parents are displaced after school completion. Job loss during infancy (ages 0–1) reduces ninth-grade mathematics achievement by 0.04 standard deviations and raises non-completion by 1 percentage point. Effects are smaller in later childhood. Treated infants are 1.4 percentage points less likely to enrol in general upper-secondary programmes. We find that liquidity-constrained households drive these results, suggesting that transient income shocks create permanent educational scars.

Finding

Effect of parental job loss on grade 9 maths by the child's age at the job loss Job loss when the child is 0 to 1 lowers grade 9 maths by 0.041 SD (95% interval -0.071 to -0.010). Effects at later ages are smaller and their intervals include zero. Ages 17 to 22, after school, are the reference group. After school −0.04 SD +0.02 0 −0.02 −0.04 −0.06 0–1 Infancy 2–5 6–11 12–16 17–22 Child's age when parent lost job Effect on grade 9 maths (SD)

Parental job loss hurts children most when it hits in infancy.

Earlier work shows that losing a job harms the children of the worker, without saying whether the child's age matters. We use Danish plant closures, match exposed children to similar peers, and difference out the selection that does not vary with the child's age by using parents displaced after school has ended. A job loss in a child's first two years lowers ninth-grade maths by 0.04 SD, and the families who cannot borrow their way through the shock drive the result. Job losses later in childhood do much less harm.

Dots are effects by the child's age when the parent lost their job, with 95% intervals. The grey dot is the after-school group everything is compared against.

Cite

@article{bingley2026hurts,
  author  = {Paul Bingley and Lorenzo Cappellari and Marco Ovidi},
  title   = {When It Hurts the Most: Timing of Parental Job Loss and a Child's Education},
  journal = {Journal of the European Economic Association},
  year    = {2026},
  doi     = {10.1093/jeea/jvag048}
}

All publications