Journal Submissions

The journal submissions of my papers from 1992 to 2026, and the decisions on them, counted in aggregate.

From 1992 to 2026, 56 of my papers went to journals 127 times and received 38 acceptances, 57 rejections, 16 desk rejections and 37 revision requests. Of the 56 papers, 38 were accepted. The other 18 have not been, eight of them with a submission or a decision since November 2024 and ten without, and they received 34 of the 73 rejections and desk rejections.

A first decision took a median of three months. For the 30 accepted papers with a dated start, the median from first trace to acceptance was 59 months, and 84 percent of the months that can be assigned were spent with the authors. The Grant Applications page counts the applications to funders the same way.

Where the Months Went

Where the months went, from a paper's first trace to its acceptance or its latest journal stage For all 30 accepted papers, 64 months on average from the first trace to acceptance, of which 42% writing, up to the first submission, 15% revising, after a revision request, 13% after a rejection, up to the next journal, 6% at journals that did not accept it, 7% at the journal that accepted it, 17% date not found. Drawn for 6 groups of papers. Accepted, started 1991 to 1999 · 7 papers · 98 months on average 24% 26% 20% 7% 7% 14% Accepted, started 2000 to 2009 · 10 papers · 43 months on average 42% 5% 6% 4% 9% 35% Accepted, started 2010 to 2021 · 13 papers · 63 months on average 57% 11% 9% 6% 7% 10% All accepted papers · 30 papers · 64 months on average 42% 15% 13% 6% 7% 17% Never accepted, journal activity since November 2024 · 8 papers · 77 months on average 91% 4% 4% Never accepted, no journal activity since November 2024 · 10 papers · 94 months on average 68% 19% 7% 4% With the authors Writing, up to the first submission Revising, after a revision request After a rejection, up to the next journal With the journals At journals that did not accept it At the journal that accepted it Date not found
The months from the first trace of a paper to its acceptance, for 30 accepted papers, split into time with the authors and time with the journals. For papers never accepted the clock stops at the last recorded submission or decision. Work often began before the first trace, so the writing share is if anything understated. "Date not found" is time between two recorded stages with a date missing between them.

The Graveyard

Papers by how each has fared, and rejections by the fate of the paper 56 papers, by how each has fared so far: 20 accepted at the first journal, 18 accepted at a later journal, 8 journal activity since November 2024, 10 no journal activity since November 2024. 73 rejections, by the fate of the paper they went to: 39 papers accepted in the end, 13 papers with journal activity since November 2024, 21 papers with no journal activity since November 2024. 56 papers, by how each has fared so far 20 (36%) 18 (32%) 8 (14%) 10 (18%) Accepted at the first journal Accepted at a later journal Journal activity since November 2024 No journal activity since November 2024 73 rejections, by the fate of the paper they went to 39 (53%) 13 (18%) 21 (29%) Papers accepted in the end Papers with journal activity since November 2024 Papers with no journal activity since November 2024
Every paper sent to a journal by how it has fared so far, and every rejection by the fate of the paper it went to. Rejections of papers that were accepted in the end are in light blue. A paper with no submission or decision since November 2024 counts as having no journal activity; some of these may yet be sent out again, and some with recent activity are not at a journal now.

Submissions by Year

Journal submissions by year, by how each one ended 127 submissions from 1992 to 2026: 38 accepted, 4 rejected after a revision, 58 rejected, 16 desk-rejected, 2 under review or revision, 9 outcome not on file. The busiest years were 2025 with 11 and 2017 with 9. 0 4 8 12 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 Submissions Accepted Rejected after a revision Rejected Desk-rejected Under review or revision Outcome not on file
Journal submissions by the year they were sent, coloured by how each one ended. When the sending date is not on record, the year of the first recorded stage stands in for it. "Outcome not on file" marks a submission whose decision was not found, and "rejected" includes submissions known only to have gone to another journal afterwards.

Decisions by Year

Editorial decisions by year 148 editorial decisions from 1992 to 2026: 38 acceptances, 37 revision requests, 57 rejections, 16 desk rejections. Acceptances and revision requests are drawn above the line and rejections and desk rejections below it. 8 4 0 4 8 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 Acceptances and revision requests Rejections and desk rejections Decisions Acceptance Revision request Rejection Desk rejection
Editorial decisions by year, with acceptances and revision requests above the line and rejections and desk rejections below it. One journal can ask for several revisions of the same paper. An acceptance with no letter on record is dated by the proofs or the publication.

What Happened to a Submission

The first decision on a submission, and how a revision request ended First decision on record, 104 submissions: 7 acceptance, 29 revision request, 52 rejection, 16 desk rejection. After a revision request, 30 submissions: 23 acceptance, 4 rejection, 2 still under revision, 1 outcome not on file. First decision on record, 104 submissions 7 (7%) 29 (28%) 52 (50%) 16 (15%) Acceptance Revision request Rejection Desk rejection After a revision request, 30 submissions 23 (77%) 4 (13%) 2 (7%) 1 Acceptance Rejection Still under revision Outcome not on file
The first decision on each submission, and how the submissions that received a revision request ended.

Time to a First Decision

Completed months from submission to the first decision 93 submissions with both dates on record, by completed months from submission to the first decision: 16 ended in a desk rejection, 47 ended in a rejection, 30 ended in a revision request or acceptance. The commonest wait was 2 months, with 20 submissions, and every desk rejection came inside the first month. 0 5 10 15 20 25 Under 1 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10+ Completed months from submission to the first decision Submissions Desk rejection Rejection Revision request or acceptance
Completed months from submission to the first decision, for 93 submissions with both dates on record.

Journals Tried

How many journals each paper went to Accepted papers: 20 at 1, 8 at 2, 5 at 3, 5 at 4+; Papers never accepted: 8 at 1, 5 at 2, 0 at 3, 5 at 4+. 0 5 10 15 20 25 20 8 1 8 5 2 5 0 3 5 5 4+ Journals the paper went to Papers Accepted papers Papers never accepted
The number of journals each paper went to: for an accepted paper up to and including the journal that accepted it, for a paper never accepted every journal so far.

Years to Acceptance

Completed years from a paper's first trace to its acceptance Papers: 6 at Under 2, 3 at 2, 3 at 3, 4 at 4, 4 at 5, 3 at 6, 7 at 7+. 0 2 4 6 8 6 Under 2 3 2 3 3 4 4 4 5 3 6 7 7+ Completed years from the first trace Accepted papers
Completed years from the first trace of each accepted paper to its acceptance. Papers never accepted are not in this figure. The shortest and longest times are grouped so that every bar holds at least 3 papers.